Afghan tribes will not fit into a modern framework

The Endless War

Afghanistan has been for centuries, and remains so today, a nation built on tribalism. The figures differ but the academic consensus is that the Pushtun (aka, Pashtun, Pathan, etc.) are calculated at 42% to 36 % of the population, with the Tajik at 27% to 34%, depending on whether one accepts the CIA World Factbook figures or an unofficial compilation of past census figures, respectively.

In any case the Pushtun are the dominant tribe and the Tajik follow closely. Hazara and Uzbeks close in with about 10% each and another 13% accounts for groupings of smaller tribes. To emphasize the complexities, one must note there are approximately 60 Pushtun tribes divided into 400 sub-tribes.

The Durrani tribal federation of Pushtuns has been dominant since the 1700s, well before the British arrived. President Hamid Karzai is from the Popolzai clan of Durrani, whose two other main clans are the Barakzai and Alikojai. These three groups were favored for leadership by NATO after the Taliban were routed. Naturally, all the non-Durranis have resented the situation and the Western sponsors ever since; thus providing a convenient and ready supply of dissident fighters, with and without Taliban connections.

The Alikojai, headed by its warlord, Dad Mohammad Khan, has been battling the previously Taliban-favored sub-tribe, the Itzhakzai, in the area of the Sangin poppy-growing region of Helmand Province. Keeping track of current and traditional animosities and alliances is a continuing anthropological task for British and Canadian field intelligence, which has operational responsibility for that provincial sector.

SIX MONTHS AGO President Hamid Karzai stunned everyone by supporting the concept of not sending more foreign troops into his country. He told the German newspaper Die Welt: “More than anything else we need help to rebuild our human capital and our institutions, our army, our police force, our administrative structure, our judiciary, and so on.”

A basic knowledge of anthropology is of great value to a soldier in these times.

Karzai’s goal of “rebuilding institutions” would be fine if there had been a history of a modern administrative structure before the Taliban other than the Soviet-constructed communist bureaucracy. What Karzai may have been talking about is what the Economist referred to as “the ancient code of tribal behavior known as Pushtunwali.” This is the rule of conduct that is the ethical guide for Pushtun life.

This code is enforced by councils of tribal elders in negotiation, creating a policing mechanism known as arbakai. As fascinating as such a cultural structure may be, it really can’t be conceived of as a foundation for a modern state. How much relevance outside of Pushtun society it may have is also questionable.

Combined Security Transition Command-Afghanistan certainly questions it. We are going to develop professional, multi-ethnic, multi-cultural, politically correct Dudley Dorights focused district by focused district over the next ten years, or however long it takes, so they think.

Perhaps the essential political military lesson of Afghanistan is best learned by accepting the fact that Afghan tribes will not fit into a modern framework. Making our national strategic plans with that firmly in mind may be what the noble Hamid Karzai, the great Pushtun leader of the Popolzai clan of the Durrani tribal federation, fluent speaker of English, French, Pushto, Farsi, Dari, Urdu, Hindi has been trying to tell us. Or maybe he’s just trying to stay alive and in power. In any case, in some form or other, Afghani wars, small and large, will go on no matter outside involvement.



Filed under IW, The Forgotten War

7 responses to “Afghan tribes will not fit into a modern framework

  1. I was looking everywhere for this information. I believe that we have to use this information for divide, conquer and stabilize.

    As one person recently said, its like Iraq’s tribal situation, but different and more “tribal” in nature. We should reflect on the American indian tribal culture. Their interactions, alliances and intertribal wars are informative.

    In the end, you defeat them all by letting them defeat each other.

    I’m going to save this for my upcoming Afghanistan overview.

  2. Glad you found something worthwhile.

    We have troops of our own who are members of Indian tribes who could possibly help in dealing with the Pashtuns.

    The Taliban is still around 90% Pashtun. There has been an influx of Punjabis, Uzbeks and Chechens over the last year it seems, but still overwhelmingly Pashtun.

    Have you ever seen The Wisdom of General Crook? To my way of thinking, we need to make most of the Western troops in Afghanistan trainers and do most of the Taliban hunting with ANA. We also need to decide whether Afghanistan is a sovereign state with its own unique brand of justice or is it a protectorate upon which a facade of Western-style law enforcement will be imposed.

    Pashtun tribal society has broken down for the most part. The Soviets, the civil war and the Taliban have done to them what small pox, winter campaigns and buffalo hunters did to our Plains tribes. The Karzai regime seems to want to reduce the influence of khans and maliks even further.

    We need to find a way to attract young men with guns away from the opium cartel and Taliban and over to “our” side. We also need to put ex-Taliban to work finding and killing their ex-comrades. The Russians have a Vostok Battalion of turned Chechens that they have set loose among the Georgians. We should be able to recruit White Mountain Pashtuns to help us track down Chiricahua Pashtuns.

  3. Pingback: We will also work to increase the involvement of Afghan tribes. « Civilian Irregular Information Defense Group

  4. Pingback: One Man Human Terrain Teams for IW « Civilian Irregular Information Defense Group

  5. Pingback: Tribal Ruff Puffs « Civilian Irregular Information Defense Group

  6. Pingback: Civil Defense Forces « Civilian Irregular Information Defense Group

  7. Pingback: Mangal Tribal Police « Civilian Irregular Information Defense Group